UTILITARIANISME DAN DEONTOLOGI : ETIKA DALAM PENGAMBILAN KEPUTUSAN HUKUM
الكلمات المفتاحية:
Utilitarianism، Deontology، Legal Decisions، Legal Ethicsالملخص
This study analyzes the application of utilitarianism and deontology ethics in legal decision-making through normative legal research methods. The study of legal doctrine, legislation, and jurisprudence reveals the fundamental dialectic between these two ethical paradigms. Utilitarianism offers a consequentialistic approach that prioritizes collective benefit and social efficiency, while deontology maintains universal moral principles and the protection of absolute individual human rights. The findings of the study show that the Indonesian legal system does not absolutely adhere to one of the paradigms, but rather creates a dynamic synthesis that seeks to balance the two approaches. Through the analysis of court decisions, variations in the application of utilitarianism such as the _cost-benefit model analysis_ in electricity decisions and sustainable utilitarianism in mineral and mineral decisions were identified. On the other hand, the deontological approach is reflected in the protection of constitutional rights that cannot be compromised. This study concludes that the integration of both ethical perspectives in the normative legal framework allows the creation of a legal system that is responsive to the needs of society but still adheres to the principles of basic justice.
